醫師難忍炊粿蒸氣 法官:不難聞 - 嘉義
By Megan
at 2013-10-06T15:44
at 2013-10-06T15:44
Table of Contents
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板 #1IKGlo43 ]
作者: Xhocer (以前也很快樂) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 醫師難忍炊粿蒸氣 法官:不難聞
時間: Sun Oct 6 15:06:22 2013
http://tinyurl.com/p7d8dac
醫師難忍炊粿蒸氣 法官:不難聞
【聯合報╱記者曹馥年、陳永順、鄭惠仁/連線報導】 2013.10.06 03:52 am
嘉義市張姓醫師興訟排除隔壁粿店炊粿蒸氣侵入住家等侵害。一審以蒸氣含食物味道,影
響休息與睡眠,判粿店賠十五萬元,二審判定蒸氣的淡淡粿味並非不好聞,粿店勝訴免賠
。
「法官住家旁如果有這種生活環境,是否受得了?」張醫師表示,無法接受判決結果,將
上訴。
「感謝司法還我工作權!」粿店謝姓老闆說,炊粿時間原本從早上六點卅分開始,因張醫
師抱怨才改成七點,此刻張醫師家人已陸續出門上班、上學,應該不會受炊粿蒸氣影響作
息,且其他鄰居十年來不曾抱怨炊粿,還有人說味道很香。
謝老闆在嘉義市鬧區開粿店,六年來常被張醫師檢舉炊粿產生蒸氣、噪音和震動聲,影響
睡眠。環保局多次稽查,認定蒸氣沒異味,噪音和震動聲都未達到管制標準,白天最多四
十七點五分貝,未超過法定標準七十分貝,張決定向法院請求排除侵害。
一審法官認為,雖然噪音未達管制標準,但營業時造成的聲響,確實會侵害張醫師的居住
安寧;含食物味道的大量蒸氣也會影響休息與睡眠,判決粿店敗訴並賠償十五萬元精神撫
慰金。
台南高分院合議庭審理時也到現場勘查,發現蒸氣並未入侵張醫師屋內,且空氣中只有淡
淡粿味,並無異味。雖然張提供美國的研究報告,證明噪音影響生活品質,但法官指台、
美環境不同,無法比較,改判張醫師敗訴。
--
Sent from my B.B.Call
--
作者: Xhocer (以前也很快樂) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 醫師難忍炊粿蒸氣 法官:不難聞
時間: Sun Oct 6 15:06:22 2013
http://tinyurl.com/p7d8dac
醫師難忍炊粿蒸氣 法官:不難聞
【聯合報╱記者曹馥年、陳永順、鄭惠仁/連線報導】 2013.10.06 03:52 am
嘉義市張姓醫師興訟排除隔壁粿店炊粿蒸氣侵入住家等侵害。一審以蒸氣含食物味道,影
響休息與睡眠,判粿店賠十五萬元,二審判定蒸氣的淡淡粿味並非不好聞,粿店勝訴免賠
。
「法官住家旁如果有這種生活環境,是否受得了?」張醫師表示,無法接受判決結果,將
上訴。
「感謝司法還我工作權!」粿店謝姓老闆說,炊粿時間原本從早上六點卅分開始,因張醫
師抱怨才改成七點,此刻張醫師家人已陸續出門上班、上學,應該不會受炊粿蒸氣影響作
息,且其他鄰居十年來不曾抱怨炊粿,還有人說味道很香。
謝老闆在嘉義市鬧區開粿店,六年來常被張醫師檢舉炊粿產生蒸氣、噪音和震動聲,影響
睡眠。環保局多次稽查,認定蒸氣沒異味,噪音和震動聲都未達到管制標準,白天最多四
十七點五分貝,未超過法定標準七十分貝,張決定向法院請求排除侵害。
一審法官認為,雖然噪音未達管制標準,但營業時造成的聲響,確實會侵害張醫師的居住
安寧;含食物味道的大量蒸氣也會影響休息與睡眠,判決粿店敗訴並賠償十五萬元精神撫
慰金。
台南高分院合議庭審理時也到現場勘查,發現蒸氣並未入侵張醫師屋內,且空氣中只有淡
淡粿味,並無異味。雖然張提供美國的研究報告,證明噪音影響生活品質,但法官指台、
美環境不同,無法比較,改判張醫師敗訴。
--
Sent from my B.B.Call
--
Tags:
嘉義
All Comments
By Jessica
at 2013-10-08T12:40
at 2013-10-08T12:40
By Valerie
at 2013-10-10T09:36
at 2013-10-10T09:36
By Dora
at 2013-10-12T06:32
at 2013-10-12T06:32
By Barb Cronin
at 2013-10-14T03:27
at 2013-10-14T03:27
By Suhail Hany
at 2013-10-16T00:23
at 2013-10-16T00:23
By Kama
at 2013-10-17T21:19
at 2013-10-17T21:19
By Kama
at 2013-10-19T18:15
at 2013-10-19T18:15
By Blanche
at 2013-10-21T15:11
at 2013-10-21T15:11
By Dora
at 2013-10-23T12:07
at 2013-10-23T12:07
By Charlie
at 2013-10-25T09:02
at 2013-10-25T09:02
By Jake
at 2013-10-27T05:58
at 2013-10-27T05:58
By Tom
at 2013-10-29T02:54
at 2013-10-29T02:54
By Andy
at 2013-10-30T23:50
at 2013-10-30T23:50
By Odelette
at 2013-11-01T20:46
at 2013-11-01T20:46
By Steve
at 2013-11-03T17:42
at 2013-11-03T17:42
By Ethan
at 2013-11-05T14:38
at 2013-11-05T14:38
By Charlotte
at 2013-11-07T11:33
at 2013-11-07T11:33
By Hedy
at 2013-11-09T08:29
at 2013-11-09T08:29
By Ethan
at 2013-11-11T05:25
at 2013-11-11T05:25
By Belly
at 2013-11-13T02:21
at 2013-11-13T02:21
By Hamiltion
at 2013-11-14T23:17
at 2013-11-14T23:17
By Bennie
at 2013-11-16T20:13
at 2013-11-16T20:13
By Elizabeth
at 2013-11-18T17:09
at 2013-11-18T17:09
By Carolina Franco
at 2013-11-20T14:04
at 2013-11-20T14:04
By Edwina
at 2013-11-22T11:00
at 2013-11-22T11:00
By Jack
at 2013-11-24T07:56
at 2013-11-24T07:56
By Charlotte
at 2013-11-26T04:52
at 2013-11-26T04:52
By James
at 2013-11-28T01:48
at 2013-11-28T01:48
By Barb Cronin
at 2013-11-29T22:44
at 2013-11-29T22:44
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2013-12-01T19:39
at 2013-12-01T19:39
By Edith
at 2013-12-03T16:35
at 2013-12-03T16:35
By Belly
at 2013-12-05T13:31
at 2013-12-05T13:31
By Valerie
at 2013-12-07T10:27
at 2013-12-07T10:27
By Jacob
at 2013-12-09T07:23
at 2013-12-09T07:23
By Callum
at 2013-12-11T04:19
at 2013-12-11T04:19
By Ophelia
at 2013-12-13T01:15
at 2013-12-13T01:15
By Yuri
at 2013-12-14T22:10
at 2013-12-14T22:10
By Yuri
at 2013-12-16T19:06
at 2013-12-16T19:06
By Blanche
at 2013-12-18T16:02
at 2013-12-18T16:02
By Olivia
at 2013-12-20T12:58
at 2013-12-20T12:58
By Isabella
at 2013-12-22T09:54
at 2013-12-22T09:54
By Kama
at 2013-12-24T06:50
at 2013-12-24T06:50
By James
at 2013-12-26T03:46
at 2013-12-26T03:46
By Annie
at 2013-12-28T00:41
at 2013-12-28T00:41
By Anthony
at 2013-12-29T21:37
at 2013-12-29T21:37
By Doris
at 2013-12-31T18:33
at 2013-12-31T18:33
By Elma
at 2014-01-02T15:29
at 2014-01-02T15:29
By Iris
at 2014-01-04T12:25
at 2014-01-04T12:25
By Robert
at 2014-01-06T09:21
at 2014-01-06T09:21
By Una
at 2014-01-08T06:16
at 2014-01-08T06:16
By Eartha
at 2014-01-10T03:12
at 2014-01-10T03:12
By Mary
at 2014-01-12T00:08
at 2014-01-12T00:08
By Olga
at 2014-01-13T21:04
at 2014-01-13T21:04
By Eartha
at 2014-01-15T18:00
at 2014-01-15T18:00
By Frederica
at 2014-01-17T14:56
at 2014-01-17T14:56
By Charlie
at 2014-01-19T11:52
at 2014-01-19T11:52
By Mason
at 2014-01-21T08:47
at 2014-01-21T08:47
By Thomas
at 2014-01-23T05:43
at 2014-01-23T05:43
By Doris
at 2014-01-25T02:39
at 2014-01-25T02:39
By Kristin
at 2014-01-26T23:35
at 2014-01-26T23:35
By Jessica
at 2014-01-28T20:31
at 2014-01-28T20:31
By Lauren
at 2014-01-30T17:27
at 2014-01-30T17:27
By Sierra Rose
at 2014-02-01T14:23
at 2014-02-01T14:23
By Freda
at 2014-02-03T11:18
at 2014-02-03T11:18
By Enid
at 2014-02-05T08:14
at 2014-02-05T08:14
By Skylar Davis
at 2014-02-07T05:10
at 2014-02-07T05:10
By Jacky
at 2014-02-09T02:06
at 2014-02-09T02:06
By Annie
at 2014-02-10T23:02
at 2014-02-10T23:02
By Ivy
at 2014-02-12T19:58
at 2014-02-12T19:58
By Faithe
at 2014-02-14T16:53
at 2014-02-14T16:53
By Zanna
at 2014-02-16T13:49
at 2014-02-16T13:49
By Adele
at 2014-02-18T10:45
at 2014-02-18T10:45
By John
at 2014-02-20T07:41
at 2014-02-20T07:41
By Robert
at 2014-02-22T04:37
at 2014-02-22T04:37
By Michael
at 2014-02-24T01:33
at 2014-02-24T01:33
By Edwina
at 2014-02-25T22:29
at 2014-02-25T22:29
By Oliver
at 2014-02-27T19:24
at 2014-02-27T19:24
By Necoo
at 2014-03-01T16:20
at 2014-03-01T16:20
By Bethany
at 2014-03-03T13:16
at 2014-03-03T13:16
By Olivia
at 2014-03-05T10:12
at 2014-03-05T10:12
By Yedda
at 2014-03-07T07:08
at 2014-03-07T07:08
By Delia
at 2014-03-09T04:04
at 2014-03-09T04:04
By Rosalind
at 2014-03-11T01:00
at 2014-03-11T01:00
By Isabella
at 2014-03-12T21:55
at 2014-03-12T21:55
By Liam
at 2014-03-14T18:51
at 2014-03-14T18:51
By Christine
at 2014-03-16T15:47
at 2014-03-16T15:47
By Emma
at 2014-03-18T12:43
at 2014-03-18T12:43
By Heather
at 2014-03-20T09:39
at 2014-03-20T09:39
By Frederic
at 2014-03-22T06:35
at 2014-03-22T06:35
By Oscar
at 2014-03-24T03:30
at 2014-03-24T03:30
By Adele
at 2014-03-26T00:26
at 2014-03-26T00:26
By Brianna
at 2014-03-27T21:22
at 2014-03-27T21:22
By Iris
at 2014-03-29T18:18
at 2014-03-29T18:18
By Freda
at 2014-03-31T15:14
at 2014-03-31T15:14
By Adele
at 2014-04-02T12:10
at 2014-04-02T12:10
By Susan
at 2014-04-04T09:06
at 2014-04-04T09:06
By Queena
at 2014-04-06T06:01
at 2014-04-06T06:01
By Ophelia
at 2014-04-08T02:57
at 2014-04-08T02:57
By Ula
at 2014-04-09T23:53
at 2014-04-09T23:53
By Elvira
at 2014-04-11T20:49
at 2014-04-11T20:49
By Zanna
at 2014-04-13T17:45
at 2014-04-13T17:45
By Annie
at 2014-04-15T14:41
at 2014-04-15T14:41
Related Posts
ice360冰淇淋專賣店
By Yuri
at 2013-10-06T15:34
at 2013-10-06T15:34
請問一整天都有鞭炮聲到底在那裡?
By Xanthe
at 2013-10-06T15:31
at 2013-10-06T15:31
嘉義文創園區 2013傳統藝術創新節
By Jacky
at 2013-10-06T14:22
at 2013-10-06T14:22
請問世賢路上新羽球館~~
By Andy
at 2013-10-06T13:09
at 2013-10-06T13:09
耐斯松屋周年慶
By Michael
at 2013-10-06T13:05
at 2013-10-06T13:05