過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴 - 基隆
By Audriana
at 2010-08-01T12:42
at 2010-08-01T12:42
Table of Contents
※ [本文轉錄自 biker 看板 #1CL8y5TL ]
作者: MikaHakkinen (窮人沒有追求夢想的權利) 看板: biker
標題: [新聞] 過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴
時間: Sun Aug 1 05:00:52 2010
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板 #1CL8poT7 ]
作者: MikaHakkinen (窮人沒有追求夢想的權利) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴
時間: Sun Aug 1 04:51:59 2010
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2010/new/aug/1/today-t3.htm
2010-8-1
過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴
〔記者林嘉東/基隆報導〕
八十三歲老婦過馬路,一條腿被機車撞斷成三截,住院十天,花費十萬元,她狀
告騎士,騎士沒事,她反而被檢察官起訴,她為什麼這麼倒楣?
八旬婦左腿骨斷成三截
原來,基隆地檢署認定老婦「未依規定走斑馬線」才是事故主因,女騎士並無過
失,依過失傷害罪嫌起訴她。
老婦黃秀群的兒子獲知後氣憤指出,母親被馮姓女騎士撞倒後,左腿脛骨斷成三
截,現在走路還一拐一拐,天下哪有被車撞,受傷的人反而被起訴的道理?又說,母
親住院期間女騎士不聞不問,他們才提告。
馮姓女騎士受訪時表示,她很感激檢察官還她清白,並反駁指案發後她就去醫院
探視黃婦,但黃婦的兒子一口咬定她有過失,又怪她車速太快,索賠十五萬,經基隆
市安樂區公所調解不成後,隔天就告她傷害。
女騎士強調,當時老婦從騎樓走出來,她刻意避開,朝中間雙黃線騎去,但老婦
卻繼續走來,她煞車後仍擦撞到黃婦,並未超速。
檢認定撞人騎士無過失
起訴書指出,婦人黃秀群於二月十八日上午八時許,在基隆市西定路一七三號前
穿越馬路到對街時,被馮姓女騎士撞倒,左腳脛骨骨折及頭部多處擦傷;馮女則右臉
及頭部挫傷。
檢察官調出監視器發現,黃婦為圖方便,捨左側相距約廿三公尺的斑馬線不走,
卻從基隆市西定路一七三號直接穿越馬路,是事故主因,認定她有過失。
檢察官也查知,馮女騎在三.二公尺寬道路上,黃婦開始穿越道路時,馮女與黃
婦之間僅隔三、四公尺,很難期望馮女在如此短的距離能即時閃避突然闖入車道的黃
婦,故認定馮女無過失。
法界指出,若法院審理後認為女騎士無過失,判處老婦有罪,女騎士還可以提出
民事侵權損害賠償訴訟,向黃姓老婦求償醫藥費及車損。
主任檢察官周啟勇呼籲,行人要穿越未設有行人穿越設施的馬路時,須確定左、
右無來車後才能迅速穿越;本案黃婦不顧左側已有車輛駛近,仍貿然穿越馬路,是導
致行人跌倒與騎士摔車受傷的主因,檢察官才將她起訴。
在行人優先的原則下,台灣人大多認為撞人的一定理虧,本案則顛覆此一觀念,
類似案例過去亦有。
九十八年三月,男子許振家在北縣穿越馬路時貪圖方便,未依規定走斑馬線且闖
紅燈,導致機車騎士閃避不及摔車,再遭後方轎車撞死。刑事部分,許某被依過失致
死罪判刑十月,民事部分,高院判他賠兩百一十一萬元。 九十四年六月, 游姓女子
駕車撞死蘇姓婦人,被依過失致死罪起訴,但法官認為,蘇婦違規在先,且突然從快
車道走出,游女反應不及才撞死她,基於「信賴原則」,游女無過失,判她無罪。
法界人士指出,在行人優先的原則下,撞死人者多半會被認定有過失而判有罪,
但前述案例很值得行人警惕。
資料來源:自由電子報
--
阿囧津真矢-女王的招式
人都是軟弱的動物 aokman
一不小心又會背叛你的 啊啊啊啊
囧 別走! 別想跑!!!
來當我僕眾吧!<︰\ \囧/ \囧/ \囧/ \●/
我來招降你 ◢█ █ ★ █ ▲ aokman
--
作者: MikaHakkinen (窮人沒有追求夢想的權利) 看板: biker
標題: [新聞] 過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴
時間: Sun Aug 1 05:00:52 2010
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板 #1CL8poT7 ]
作者: MikaHakkinen (窮人沒有追求夢想的權利) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴
時間: Sun Aug 1 04:51:59 2010
http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2010/new/aug/1/today-t3.htm
2010-8-1
過馬路沒走斑馬線 被撞反被訴
〔記者林嘉東/基隆報導〕
八十三歲老婦過馬路,一條腿被機車撞斷成三截,住院十天,花費十萬元,她狀
告騎士,騎士沒事,她反而被檢察官起訴,她為什麼這麼倒楣?
八旬婦左腿骨斷成三截
原來,基隆地檢署認定老婦「未依規定走斑馬線」才是事故主因,女騎士並無過
失,依過失傷害罪嫌起訴她。
老婦黃秀群的兒子獲知後氣憤指出,母親被馮姓女騎士撞倒後,左腿脛骨斷成三
截,現在走路還一拐一拐,天下哪有被車撞,受傷的人反而被起訴的道理?又說,母
親住院期間女騎士不聞不問,他們才提告。
馮姓女騎士受訪時表示,她很感激檢察官還她清白,並反駁指案發後她就去醫院
探視黃婦,但黃婦的兒子一口咬定她有過失,又怪她車速太快,索賠十五萬,經基隆
市安樂區公所調解不成後,隔天就告她傷害。
女騎士強調,當時老婦從騎樓走出來,她刻意避開,朝中間雙黃線騎去,但老婦
卻繼續走來,她煞車後仍擦撞到黃婦,並未超速。
檢認定撞人騎士無過失
起訴書指出,婦人黃秀群於二月十八日上午八時許,在基隆市西定路一七三號前
穿越馬路到對街時,被馮姓女騎士撞倒,左腳脛骨骨折及頭部多處擦傷;馮女則右臉
及頭部挫傷。
檢察官調出監視器發現,黃婦為圖方便,捨左側相距約廿三公尺的斑馬線不走,
卻從基隆市西定路一七三號直接穿越馬路,是事故主因,認定她有過失。
檢察官也查知,馮女騎在三.二公尺寬道路上,黃婦開始穿越道路時,馮女與黃
婦之間僅隔三、四公尺,很難期望馮女在如此短的距離能即時閃避突然闖入車道的黃
婦,故認定馮女無過失。
法界指出,若法院審理後認為女騎士無過失,判處老婦有罪,女騎士還可以提出
民事侵權損害賠償訴訟,向黃姓老婦求償醫藥費及車損。
主任檢察官周啟勇呼籲,行人要穿越未設有行人穿越設施的馬路時,須確定左、
右無來車後才能迅速穿越;本案黃婦不顧左側已有車輛駛近,仍貿然穿越馬路,是導
致行人跌倒與騎士摔車受傷的主因,檢察官才將她起訴。
在行人優先的原則下,台灣人大多認為撞人的一定理虧,本案則顛覆此一觀念,
類似案例過去亦有。
九十八年三月,男子許振家在北縣穿越馬路時貪圖方便,未依規定走斑馬線且闖
紅燈,導致機車騎士閃避不及摔車,再遭後方轎車撞死。刑事部分,許某被依過失致
死罪判刑十月,民事部分,高院判他賠兩百一十一萬元。 九十四年六月, 游姓女子
駕車撞死蘇姓婦人,被依過失致死罪起訴,但法官認為,蘇婦違規在先,且突然從快
車道走出,游女反應不及才撞死她,基於「信賴原則」,游女無過失,判她無罪。
法界人士指出,在行人優先的原則下,撞死人者多半會被認定有過失而判有罪,
但前述案例很值得行人警惕。
資料來源:自由電子報
--
阿囧津真矢-女王的招式
人都是軟弱的動物 aokman
一不小心又會背叛你的 啊啊啊啊
囧 別走! 別想跑!!!
來當我僕眾吧!<︰\ \囧/ \囧/ \囧/ \●/
我來招降你 ◢█ █ ★ █ ▲ aokman
--
All Comments
By Barb Cronin
at 2010-08-01T20:02
at 2010-08-01T20:02
By Gilbert
at 2010-08-02T03:21
at 2010-08-02T03:21
By Ethan
at 2010-08-02T10:41
at 2010-08-02T10:41
By Caitlin
at 2010-08-02T18:01
at 2010-08-02T18:01
By Lauren
at 2010-08-03T01:20
at 2010-08-03T01:20
By Mary
at 2010-08-03T08:40
at 2010-08-03T08:40
By Agatha
at 2010-08-03T15:59
at 2010-08-03T15:59
By Kama
at 2010-08-03T23:19
at 2010-08-03T23:19
By Emily
at 2010-08-04T06:38
at 2010-08-04T06:38
By Steve
at 2010-08-04T13:58
at 2010-08-04T13:58
By Carolina Franco
at 2010-08-04T21:17
at 2010-08-04T21:17
By Wallis
at 2010-08-05T04:37
at 2010-08-05T04:37
By Liam
at 2010-08-05T11:56
at 2010-08-05T11:56
By Lauren
at 2010-08-05T19:16
at 2010-08-05T19:16
By John
at 2010-08-06T02:36
at 2010-08-06T02:36
By Enid
at 2010-08-06T09:55
at 2010-08-06T09:55
By Sandy
at 2010-08-06T17:15
at 2010-08-06T17:15
By James
at 2010-08-07T00:34
at 2010-08-07T00:34
By Aaliyah
at 2010-08-07T07:54
at 2010-08-07T07:54
By Erin
at 2010-08-07T15:13
at 2010-08-07T15:13
By Andrew
at 2010-08-07T22:33
at 2010-08-07T22:33
By Charlotte
at 2010-08-08T05:52
at 2010-08-08T05:52
By Mason
at 2010-08-08T13:12
at 2010-08-08T13:12
By Thomas
at 2010-08-08T20:32
at 2010-08-08T20:32
By Hazel
at 2010-08-09T03:51
at 2010-08-09T03:51
By Quintina
at 2010-08-09T11:11
at 2010-08-09T11:11
By William
at 2010-08-09T18:30
at 2010-08-09T18:30
By Edwina
at 2010-08-10T01:50
at 2010-08-10T01:50
By Damian
at 2010-08-10T09:09
at 2010-08-10T09:09
By Isabella
at 2010-08-10T16:29
at 2010-08-10T16:29
By Leila
at 2010-08-10T23:48
at 2010-08-10T23:48
By Necoo
at 2010-08-11T07:08
at 2010-08-11T07:08
By Madame
at 2010-08-11T14:27
at 2010-08-11T14:27
By Daph Bay
at 2010-08-11T21:47
at 2010-08-11T21:47
By Ula
at 2010-08-12T05:07
at 2010-08-12T05:07
By Elvira
at 2010-08-12T12:26
at 2010-08-12T12:26
By Ursula
at 2010-08-12T19:46
at 2010-08-12T19:46
By Zanna
at 2010-08-13T03:05
at 2010-08-13T03:05
By Heather
at 2010-08-13T10:25
at 2010-08-13T10:25
By Zenobia
at 2010-08-13T17:44
at 2010-08-13T17:44
By Elma
at 2010-08-14T01:04
at 2010-08-14T01:04
By Caitlin
at 2010-08-14T08:23
at 2010-08-14T08:23
By Erin
at 2010-08-14T15:43
at 2010-08-14T15:43
By Jessica
at 2010-08-14T23:03
at 2010-08-14T23:03
By Elizabeth
at 2010-08-15T06:22
at 2010-08-15T06:22
By Zenobia
at 2010-08-15T13:42
at 2010-08-15T13:42
By Sarah
at 2010-08-15T21:01
at 2010-08-15T21:01
By Selena
at 2010-08-16T04:21
at 2010-08-16T04:21
By Jack
at 2010-08-16T11:40
at 2010-08-16T11:40
By Zora
at 2010-08-16T19:00
at 2010-08-16T19:00
By Kumar
at 2010-08-17T02:19
at 2010-08-17T02:19
By Hedy
at 2010-08-17T09:39
at 2010-08-17T09:39
By Anonymous
at 2010-08-17T16:58
at 2010-08-17T16:58
By Poppy
at 2010-08-18T00:18
at 2010-08-18T00:18
By Steve
at 2010-08-18T07:38
at 2010-08-18T07:38
By Eartha
at 2010-08-18T14:57
at 2010-08-18T14:57
By Barb Cronin
at 2010-08-18T22:17
at 2010-08-18T22:17
By Regina
at 2010-08-19T05:36
at 2010-08-19T05:36
By Margaret
at 2010-08-19T12:56
at 2010-08-19T12:56
By Freda
at 2010-08-19T20:15
at 2010-08-19T20:15
By Ida
at 2010-08-20T03:35
at 2010-08-20T03:35
By Jacob
at 2010-08-20T10:54
at 2010-08-20T10:54
By Ivy
at 2010-08-20T18:14
at 2010-08-20T18:14
By Barb Cronin
at 2010-08-21T01:34
at 2010-08-21T01:34
By Bethany
at 2010-08-21T08:53
at 2010-08-21T08:53
By Andrew
at 2010-08-21T16:13
at 2010-08-21T16:13
By Ivy
at 2010-08-21T23:32
at 2010-08-21T23:32
By Ingrid
at 2010-08-22T06:52
at 2010-08-22T06:52
By Linda
at 2010-08-22T14:11
at 2010-08-22T14:11
By Gary
at 2010-08-22T21:31
at 2010-08-22T21:31
By Elvira
at 2010-08-23T04:50
at 2010-08-23T04:50
By Noah
at 2010-08-23T12:10
at 2010-08-23T12:10
By Caroline
at 2010-08-23T19:29
at 2010-08-23T19:29
By Linda
at 2010-08-24T02:49
at 2010-08-24T02:49
By Emma
at 2010-08-24T10:09
at 2010-08-24T10:09
By William
at 2010-08-24T17:28
at 2010-08-24T17:28
By Isabella
at 2010-08-25T00:48
at 2010-08-25T00:48
By Catherine
at 2010-08-25T08:07
at 2010-08-25T08:07
By Kelly
at 2010-08-25T15:27
at 2010-08-25T15:27
By Michael
at 2010-08-25T22:46
at 2010-08-25T22:46
By Liam
at 2010-08-26T06:06
at 2010-08-26T06:06
By David
at 2010-08-26T13:25
at 2010-08-26T13:25
By Brianna
at 2010-08-26T20:45
at 2010-08-26T20:45
By Connor
at 2010-08-27T04:05
at 2010-08-27T04:05
By Edward Lewis
at 2010-08-27T11:24
at 2010-08-27T11:24
By Agnes
at 2010-08-27T18:44
at 2010-08-27T18:44
By Poppy
at 2010-08-28T02:03
at 2010-08-28T02:03
By Agnes
at 2010-08-28T09:23
at 2010-08-28T09:23
By Todd Johnson
at 2010-08-28T16:42
at 2010-08-28T16:42
By Hedda
at 2010-08-29T00:02
at 2010-08-29T00:02
By Megan
at 2010-08-29T07:21
at 2010-08-29T07:21
By Carolina Franco
at 2010-08-29T14:41
at 2010-08-29T14:41
By Charlie
at 2010-08-29T22:00
at 2010-08-29T22:00
By Leila
at 2010-08-30T05:20
at 2010-08-30T05:20
By Hedwig
at 2010-08-30T12:40
at 2010-08-30T12:40
By Frederica
at 2010-08-30T19:59
at 2010-08-30T19:59
By Candice
at 2010-08-31T03:19
at 2010-08-31T03:19
By Carol
at 2010-08-31T10:38
at 2010-08-31T10:38
By Sandy
at 2010-08-31T17:58
at 2010-08-31T17:58
By Irma
at 2010-09-01T01:17
at 2010-09-01T01:17
Related Posts
蠢問有人可以提供從大武崙到苗栗市的機 …
By Zenobia
at 2010-08-01T12:18
at 2010-08-01T12:18
比婓村劍心千人斬還厲害的人
By Yuri
at 2010-08-01T09:29
at 2010-08-01T09:29
車站開發案全面啟動 歐洲日本招商110億
By Zenobia
at 2010-08-01T09:27
at 2010-08-01T09:27
博X博的店員
By Lucy
at 2010-08-01T02:25
at 2010-08-01T02:25
請問東興鎖?
By Catherine
at 2010-08-01T02:20
at 2010-08-01T02:20