TPO-12 Transition to Sound in Film - 英檢

大家好 原PO你好 我也想問這題


我自己的想法是

文中提到
premiere performance
及
Berlin screenings with live music

選項 The film was not accompanied by sound before its Berlin screening.

premiere p. 並非film 而是現場live演出
premiere p.之後才有Berlin screenings with live music
所以推論選項的陳述...

但我覺得還是怪怪的@@

附上我在網路上找到的解說
5. 以Einsenstein做关键词定位至最后一句，说在柏林，电影导演才第一次与一
个作曲家合作，所以答案是A。B没说，原文只说柏林的演出带来了international fame，
没说之前unpopular；C的first collaboration没说；D的一样重要没说

http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_549342b40100rqh0.html

※ 引述《tbrsun (John Lee)》之銘言：
: Paragraph 2：Yet this most fundamental standard of historical periodization
: conceals a host of paradoxes. Nearly every movie theater, however modest, had
: a piano or organ to provide musical accompaniment to silent pictures. In many
: instances, spectators in the era before recorded sound experienced elaborate
: aural presentations alongside movies' visual images, from the Japanese benshi
: (narrators) crafting multivoiced dialogue narratives to original musical
: compositions performed by symphony-size orchestras in Europe and the United
: States. In Berlin, for the premiere performance outside the Soviet Union of
: The Battleship Potemkin, film director Sergei Eisenstein worked with Austrian
: composer Edmund Meisel (1874-1930) on a musical score matching sound to
: image; the Berlin screenings with live music helped to bring the film its
: wide international fame.
: 5. Paragraph 2 suggests which of the following about Eisenstein’s film The
: Battleship Potemkirf?
: ○ The film was not accompanied by sound before its Berlin screening.
: ○ The film was unpopular in the Soviet Union before it was screened in
: Berlin.
: ○ Eisenstein’s film was the first instance of collaboration between a
: director and a composer.
: ○ Eisenstein believed that the musical score in a film was as important as
: dialogue.
: 答案為A
: 想請問大家C答案不能選的原因?
: 文中提到 首次演出,Eisenstein和澳洲composer合作,matching sound to image.
: 後半句可以解A，但中間那句感覺也可以解C
: 兩個答案都有first的概念，一個是跟作曲家合作，一個是結合聲音
: 不知道C為什麼不能選 @@
: 麻煩大家解惑了~
: thx ^^

--