黃金閱讀 The Long-Term Stability of Ecosystems - 英檢

Table of Contents

paragraph 2 : An ecologist who studies a pond today may well find it
relatively unchanged in a year's time. Individual fish
may be replaced, but the number of fish will tend to be
the same from one year to the next. We can say that the
properties of an ecosystem are more stable than the
individual organisms that compose the ecosystem.

3. According to paragraph 2, which of the following principles of ecosystems
can be learned by studying a pond?
○Ecosystem properties change more slowly than individuals in the system.
○The stability of an ecosystem tends to chang as individuals are replaced.
○Individual organisms are stable from one year to the next.
○A chang in the members of an organism does not affect an ecosystem's
properties.

寫的時候第選項1跟選項4讓我好掙扎
因為從段落裡來看選項1好像也頗有道理(因為最後一句話,we can say that....)
難道一開始說的relatively unchanged就代表完全不影響嗎?
有點疑惑難道全部的魚的數量不變,生態的properties就不變嗎??
想請問各位這題怎麼判斷才好

謝謝^^

--

All Comments

Erin avatarErin2010-07-30
這題我也覺得 如果"只"根據第二段 1跟4似乎都可算對??
Mary avatarMary2010-08-02
但是如果看到後面對於stability的爭議點上 大概就4正確
數量的意義上不是單純的數量吧 應該意思是指 整群比例
Zora avatarZora2010-08-06
就是數量是波動 但是整體會有一個相對比例 整體相對來說
因為環境中食物鍊的互相牽制 互有消長 但是彼此都在一個
波動範圍內 所以整體properties可以說是不變
Robert avatarRobert2010-08-09
怪怪,我這版(5.6)的答案是1耶 所以改成4囉?
Hamiltion avatarHamiltion2010-08-09
要我我也會選1,4太武斷 改變得少不代表完全沒有阿
William avatarWilliam2010-08-13
僅個人想法
Skylar Davis avatarSkylar Davis2010-08-15
恩..我再看一次字句後 我覺得應該選1 chieher說得對
Ophelia avatarOphelia2010-08-16
4有一個問題 就是講太武斷 應該說 不會有大影響 而非
沒有影響
Jacky avatarJacky2010-08-20
咦我的是29篇版本 所以答案後來改成1囉?
Sierra Rose avatarSierra Rose2010-08-24
感謝chieher
Cara avatarCara2010-08-25
我看也是1@@ 所以答案是什麼咧? (敲碗)
John avatarJohn2010-08-28
我覺得是4耶
William avatarWilliam2010-08-30
我下載到的這版答案是1 可是有人說4@@
Heather avatarHeather2010-09-01
but the number of fish will tend to be the same from
one year to the next.
文章只有說數量不太會變動。
Andrew avatarAndrew2010-09-04
沒說換人會不會造成影響吧@@?
Hardy avatarHardy2010-09-08
所以答案4不太好
Yuri avatarYuri2010-09-11
而文章的最後一句,其實就是答案1的換句話說= =+
我想1應該是對的 :)